WritingEssay
We need to rethink cybersecurity budgets
Stolen money can pay for the next attack. A defence budget that is set once a year was not built for an opponent like that.
The attackers may have a bigger budget next year.
There’s an awkward possibility that we’re helping fund it.
Where the stolen money goes
In October, The Economic Times reported an estimated ₹300 crore stolen from Indian NBFCs in roughly two months. That is a substantial loss for the industry. Some of it could also become working capital for the next round of attacks.
Suppose just 10% became available for reinvestment across the criminal operations involved. That’s ₹30 crore for more compute, better AI, more servers, proxies, developers and operators.
The arithmetic
- ₹300 crorereported stolen from NBFCs in about two months
- 10%suppose this much is reinvested
- ₹30 crorefor compute, AI, servers, proxies, developers and operators
A successful theft can become the seed round for a much larger operation. Once a method works, there is every incentive to try it against ten more lenders.
Meanwhile, another security engineer can still require a business case explaining why the existing team cannot simply “stretch”.
How AI changes the attacker’s arithmetic
Sun Tzu advised feeding an army from the enemy’s supplies. Cybercrime has found a remarkably literal interpretation: Anthropic recently documented attackers stealing victims’ AI access keys and using them to power further attacks. The victims were effectively picking up the AI bill.
Sun Tzu, meet cloud billing.
And AI makes the economics more uncomfortable. CERT-In’s November advisory describes offensive tools that generate attack scripts, adapt them to the target’s responses and execute attack chains autonomously. It also reports organisations being attacked again after incomplete fixes.
The attacker gets more attempts out of every rupee. Successful attempts can provide more rupees.
The cycle
- A theft succeeds
- Part of the proceeds is reinvested
- More compute, better AI, more operators
- More attempts out of every rupee
A successful attempt starts the loop again
The defence programmeSet once a year: headcount, testing frequency and capacity to fix.
What a defence budget is for
What worries me is putting that cycle up against a defence programme whose headcount, testing frequency and capacity to fix things barely change.
Renew the tools. Schedule the assessment. Negotiate the increase.
A familiar routine. The opponent is becoming rather less familiar.
We don’t have to match criminal spending rupee for rupee. But we should care whether our ability to defend is growing as quickly as their ability to attack.
Last year’s budget is a useful accounting reference. It is a questionable military strategy.
Especially when the other side can finance its next campaign with the money we were trying to protect.
Sources
- The Economic Times, 29 October 2026: an estimated ₹300 crore stolen from Indian NBFCs in about two months.
- Anthropic, Threat Intelligence Report, September 2026: stolen AI API keys used to run further attacks at the victims’ expense.
- YourStory, November 2026, reporting CERT-In advisory CIAD-2026-0058: offensive AI tools that generate, adapt and run attack chains.